Despite her broken heart, when Dilly Gently joins Magnus Olensen's new band, the chemistry between them is explosive. Both impossibly romantic blondes with the souls of poets, they seem to be made for one another. But before they have chance to declare their affections, Dilly's friend Nell confides that she has a huge crush on Magnus, and Dilly nobly steps down in order to play the reluctant matchmaker. Nell returns the favor by setting Dilly up with her dashing twin brother, Flipper. But Flipper is not a good rebound for a true romantic: he hides a secret that could break Dilly's heart all over again.